Dr Raymond Lam (University of British Columbia) gives a public talk on seasonal affective disorder (SAD) and light
therapy at a Scientific Conference of the Society for Light Treatment
and Biological Rhythms (www.sltbr.org) held on June 28, 2008 in
Vancouver, Canada.
SAD Seasonal Affective Disorder Seasonal
Affective Disorder (SAD) is a specific type of major depression, one
which reoccurs at specific times of the year. The most common pattern
is the onset of major depression in the fall (September through
November) and abating of the symptoms in late winter to early spring
(March through May). There are other people who experience periods of
abnormally high or euphoric mood between major depressive episodes. The
frequency of SAD seems to vary with geographic location. It may
approach 10% of the general population in northern New England, 5% of
the population in the Baltimore/Washington area, and less than 2% of
the population of Southern California or Florida.About
3/4 of S.A.D. sufferers are women, but S.A.D. affects men and children
as well. The most typical age of onset is in the twenties, but other
onsets are common such as during puberty, middle age, and old age.
After women pass through menopause the numbers in men and women become
equal. Susceptibility for S.A.D appears to be inherited. Fifty percent
of fibromyalgia patients see a seasonal worsening of their symptoms. A major depression, seasonal or otherwise, is characterized by a series of symptoms: Symptoms of S.A.D. may include the following:
- Change in appetite or weight
- Sleep problems
- Lack of energy
- Diminishing sex drive
- Body aches or pains
- Memory loss
- Inability to make decisions
- Problems concentrating
- Low self-esteem (feelings of worthlessness or guilt)
- Lack of interest in or enjoyment of activities
- Suicidal thoughts
SAD Treatment In
many ways, the treatment of SAD is similar to that of other major
depressive episodes, utilizing antidepressant or mood stabilizing
medication and/or psychotherapy. In addition, the exposure to bright
light has been found to be an effective means of treating seasonal
affective disorder. The individual sits in front of a bright light
unit, a specialized, portable box which houses balanced spectrum
fluorescent tubes. An individual's needs for light therapy specifies
the duration of exposure and the optimal time of day. An individual
should meet periodically with their health care professional and the
dose of light therapy can be adjusted as needed.
How the light box works The
light box provides a measured amount of balanced spectrum light
equivalent to standing outdoors on a clear spring day. This has been
shown to help regulate the body clock. Photobiologists point out that
the light is registered by the eyes through the retina, which then
transfers impulses to the hypothalamus in the brain to normalize the
body clock function. The light from the box will help synchronize
sleep/wake patterns with ones work and life style.
Factors Influencing Severity S.A.D.
can be experienced as an isolated disorder or may be experienced in
conjunction with an existing mood disorder or chronic illness. The
tendency toward S.A.D. or severity of the symptoms can be influenced by
many factors, such as living in a northern latitude, recent cloudy
weather patterns, family history of S.A.D., working in a windowless
office, recent illness, or general life stresses.
Causes of SAD Change
in sunlight exposure is the key. The amount of day light exposure one
receives and the changes in sunrise/sunset reducing the daylight hours
in the fall and winter can affect suffers of S.A.D. The most commonly
believed hypothesis follows: although the body has natural daily
rhythms, they are not fully precise and rely on the intensity of
sunlight to provide adjusting cues. These cues originate in the retina
at the back of the eye, creating signals which pass through the optic
nerve to the mid brain, setting in motion a number of chemical changes.
These changes include: 1) Increase in the neurotransmitter serotonin, necessary for a sense of well being.
2) Regulation and suppression of the hormone melatonin, which is a
factor in normal sleep patterns and may influence sleeps recuperative
benefits.
Basics of Bright Light Therapy Devices The
most common device used for bright light therapy is a fluorescent light
box which produces a light intensity of 2,500 to 10,000 lux at a
comfortable distance (1-2'). Light box intensity ratings are always at
a given distance. Light weight portable boxes and those mounted on a
stand are available. Full-spectrum light is not necessary since
intensity is most important, but a balanced-spectrum light minus UV-B
emissions is considered ideal. Fewer headaches and eyestrain are
associated with using balanced spectrum light. Most light boxes cost
from $250 to $525. Light visors which use a battery pack, are worn on
the head and allow for mobility. Light Visors appear to be at least as
effective as light boxes because the light source is close to the
eyes. Dawn/dusk simulators are rheostat timers which are used in
conjunction with a bedside lamp. These units gradually turn on the lamp
light over a preset or variable period of time. Dawn/dusk simulators
appear to be most effective for those with mild symptoms, for those who
did not succeed with bright light therapy, and for those who have
success with bright light therapy but still have difficulty waking up.
The
light box is placed in front of the user at the recommended distance
for the desired intensity. One should be directly in front of the unit
as the light shines into the users eyes. The eyes need be open, and
sunglasses should not be worn. Some may be instructed to look at the
light box briefly at regular intervals. For many this doesn't seem to
be necessary. The light box intensity of 10,000 lux is much brighter
than normal indoor light which is usually 300-500 lux, but not as
bright as summer sunlight which can be as bright as 100,000 lux.
Session Length Exposure
time is determined by the intensity of the light source . There are
individual differences, but a 1/2 hour treatment at 10,000 lux or a 1
hour session at 5,000 lux once a day is the average. Most are
comfortable with the 10,000 lux intensity level, and choose a unit that
produces 10,000 lux at a usable and comfortable 13-16" distance from
the light box. If eyestrain occurs it may be necessary to have shorter
periodic sessions.
Bright Light Therapy Timing The
most successful treatments for S.A.D. involve identifying how the
change in daylight shifts the person's daily circadian rhythms,
especially in their sleep cycle. Most with S.A.D. symptoms show changes
in their sleep/wake patterns and melatonin levels. Bright light is
known to be a powerful regulator of melatonin and the sleep/wake cycle.
S.A.D. and "Winter Blues" sufferers tend to show two common patterns in
their sleep phase: Delayed or Advanced.
Session Timing for "Phase Delayed" Patients About
80% show this pattern, this groups melatonin production and sleep
period begin later at night, and moves into the normal morning waking
hours. These patients have trouble waking up in the morning, and often
feel sluggish for hours after awakening, even if they have slept longer
than usual. Phototherapy sessions appear to be most effective for this
group if placed between 6-8 a.m. Some experience a time during late
afternoon or early evening that they become tired. Of those in the
phase-delayed group about 50% have this tired time. Late evening
arrives and the energy levels increase, which makes going to bed at a
normal time difficult. This may also result in poor sleep quality. For
those, an optional second session of 5 to10 minutes at 10,000 lux
between 3-7 p.m. helps change this pattern and often improves sleep
quality. This additional light may cause some users difficulty going to
sleep.
Session Timing for "Phase Advanced" Patients About
20% of this group feel best in the morning, then around noon their
energy levels steadily decline. Often they retire for the night hours
earlier than normal. Their 30 minute session at 10,000 lux is usually
placed from 3-7 p.m., depending on when the urge to sleep occurs and
how late the light may be used without keeping them awake. Timing is
more individual for this group, and may require trial and error for
optimum effect. Short, periodic sessions throughout the afternoon at
high intensity, or long exposure at a lower intensity may also be
considered. A second session in the morning is often not beneficial for
this group.
Beginning and Ending Bright Light Therapy Regular
daily usage at the same time each day is best until symptoms disappear.
After that period the patient may be able to cut session time or split
a half-hour AM session into 15 minutes a.m. and p.m. Once established,
most can skip a couple of days without ill-effects, but by the third
day without light therapy most will see symptoms return. Light therapy
sessions should begin at the time of the year before symptoms become
obvious or distressing, and most patients will discontinue use in the
spring when they receive enough natural light. The times when usage is
necessary can be greatly affected by the amount of sunlight or cloudy
rainy weather.
Side Effects It
is possible to overuse a light box. After overuse for 4 - 6 weeks,
irritability and agitation which is often followed by fatigue may
result. Irritability, agitation and initial eyestrain for 1-3 days
appear to be the main side effects. Inducing mania is seen in about 1%
and any mild hypo-mania that may occur results from consistent overuse.
Some drugs make patients photosensitive, as can contact lenses, and
those patients may need to be conservative when starting light therapy.
Those on antidepressants can often reduce their dosage, with their
doctors consent, once light therapy works. For most patients, light
therapy is the most natural and safe treatment for S.A.D., as well as
the most cost-effective.
Seeking Treatment Given
the effectiveness of treatments for S.A.D. it would be a shame for
anyone not to seek help. It is true that S.A.D. is often correctly
self-diagnosed and anyone can purchase light devices, but other illness
factors may be at play, and seeking the guidance of a qualified medical
practitioner in both the diagnosis and treatment of S.A.D. is the
wisest thing to do. (Usage patterns outlined herein represent those
most typically given by current clinical practices. They are not
intended to encourage self-prescription or to contradict an
individual's prescribed therapy.)
Seeking Treatment Given
the effectiveness of treatments for S.A.D. it would be a shame for
anyone not to seek help. It is true that S.A.D. is often correctly
self-diagnosed and anyone can purchase light devices, but other illness
factors may be at play, and seeking the guidance of a qualified medical
practitioner in both the diagnosis and treatment of S.A.D. is the
wisest thing to do. (Usage patterns outlined herein represent those
most typically given by current clinical practices. They are not
intended to encourage self-prescription or to contradict an
individual's prescribed therapy.)
|